Log Out

Miners say UBB mine cheated on dust sampling

David Deal for NPR
Patty and Gary Quarles lost their son, Gary Wayne Quarles, in the explosion at Upper Big Branch mine. Their son's post-mortem indicated he had black lung, a puzzling diagnosis since he was only 33.
Lawrence Pierce
Special investigator Davitt McAteer found that many of the miners who died at Upper Big Branch also showed signs of having black lung disease.
Read more: The new face of black lungDust reforms stalled by years of inaction CHARLSTON, W.Va. -- Evidence from the Upper Big Branch Mine Disaster investigation shows not only that black lung is back, but also one reason the deadly disease is again on the rise.Falsification of the dust sampling used to enforce federal black lung protections was common at Upper Big Branch, according to miners who worked at the Massey Energy operation.To measure coal dust that causes black lung, some miners wear sampling devices commonly called dust pumps. In order to ensure accurate monitoring, it's important that miners work in the same areas and do the same jobs they would normally do when not wearing the pumps.But Mike Kimblinger, a construction foreman who worked at Upper Big Branch for more than 14 years, told federal and state investigators that wasn't the way it worked."I was told to stay away from the dust and not do certain things while I was wearing the dust pump," Kimblinger said in sworn testimony. He said such instructions to miners were common at Upper Big Branch, and were given by top mine managers. Former MSHA chief Davitt McAteer led a team of investigators who conducted an independent probe of the April 5, 2010, explosion that killed 29 miners at Upper Big Branch.McAteer and his team obtained autopsy reports for the miners who died, and had a black lung expert examine them for evidence of the disease. Of the 24 victims with sufficient lung tissue for the analysis, 17 of them -- or 71 percent -- were found to have black lung.This compares to the national black lung rate among miners of 3.2 percent, and the West Virginia rate of 7.6 percent, the McAteer report noted.
"At least four of the 17 worked almost exclusively at UBB," the report said. "All but one of the 17 victims with [black lung] began working in the mines after the 2.0 milligram coal mine dust limit was put in effect in 1973."Mark Edwards, who ran a shuttle car at Upper Big Branch, told investigators the company cut back from two continuous miners to one such machine on days when workers were wearing dust pumps."They didn't care about coal that day," Edwards testified. "Any other day, we're running two miners. It was so dusty down there it was awful."I thought, man, something isn't right with this," Edwards said. "And I think there was -- I mean, I would hear the boss tell the miner man, stay back out of the entry. Don't go up there where the dust is. Stay back."Miner Bruce Vickers had worked at Upper Big Branch since 1995. When he would wear a dust pump, mine managers told him to sit in the mine's fresh air intake tunnel, and let somebody else do his work, Vickers told investigators.
"Well, if they can ... keep me in the intake, in fresh air, then that's what they'll do," Vickers said.Vickers said he testified in 1998 to a federal grand jury that asked him about dust pump falsification at Upper Big Branch.Court records and government documents don't show any charges ever being brought.Reach Ken Ward Jr. at or 304-348-1702.Our stories about black lung were jointly reported by the Center for Public Integrity and NPR News as part of "Hard Labor," an occasional series on health, safety and economic threats to U.S. workers. Additional reporting was provided by Charleston Gazette staff writer Ken Ward Jr. Read more in Monday's Gazette and on the CPI website, Hear more about black lung Monday on NPR's All Things Considered and Tuesday on NPR's Morning Edition. Additional NPR stories are available at 
Show All Comments Hide All Comments

User Comments

More News