Log Out

Capito reviewing revamped GOP health bill; medical groups urge ‘no’ vote

AP file photo

With all eyes on Sen. Shelley Moore Capito, R-W.Va., as she reviews the latest draft of the GOP-backed Affordable Care Act replacement, a coalition of health care groups held a news conference Thursday where they urged her to hold her position in opposing the bill.

Speakers at Charleston Area Medical Center’s Cancer Center offered research, projections and personal anecdotes detailing how the bill could harm West Virginians at the Thursday morning conference, just hours before Senate leadership released the newest tweaks to their Better Care Reconciliation Act.

Thursday’s changes include reintroducing taxes on the wealthy, Sen. Ted Cruz’s idea of allowing insurance providers to offer plans that do not comply with the Affordable Care Act, as long as they also offer plans that do, and adding $45 billion in funding to combat the nation’s opioid epidemic.

Capito came out against the original version of the bill, citing cuts to the ACA’s Medicaid expansion and insufficient funding to handle the opioid epidemic. In a later interview, she said she also opposed Cruz’s proposal.

Since the new bill does not substantially alter what the Congressional Budget Office estimated to be $772 billion in cuts to Medicaid expansion, contains the Cruz-backed language and the opioid funding, Capito’s vote could be up-in-the-air, as well as pivotal, given the Republican party’s two-seat Senate majority.

In a statement from her press office, Capito said she is still reviewing the legislation.

“Any health care bill to replace Obamacare must provide access to affordable health care coverage for West Virginians, including our large Medicaid population and those struggling with drug addiction,” she said. “I opposed the previous draft because it did not ensure access to affordable health care in West Virginia, did not do enough to combat the opioid epidemic that is devastating my state, cut Medicaid too deeply, and harmed rural health care providers. I look forward to reviewing the revised Senate health care legislation and forthcoming CBO report to determine the impact on West Virginians, but continue to have serious concerns about the Medicaid provisions.”

Meanwhile, in Charleston, speakers from groups such as AARP, the American Hospital Association and the American Cancer Society spoke out against the bill and urged Capito, despite enormous political pressure, to vote against it.

Dr. Rahul Gupta, state Health Officer and Commissioner for the Bureau of Public Health, said the bill would not solve skyrocketing health care costs and will lower insurance costs only by removing people from coverage.

“What it will basically do is either shift costs or throw those people in an arena that they will not know how to get charity care, and they will be at the mercy of charity care systems, which we actually have worked to wind down in a lot of ways since the Affordable Care Act,” he said. “We’ve been working a different direction, and this is actually going to take us in a 180 degree turn.”

He pointed out that, of the roughly 170,000 West Virginians covered under the Medicaid expansion from the ACA, 50,000 of them have a substance abuse disorder.

“We’re not only talking about bringing insurance costs down, we’re talking about bringing insurance costs down by getting people off the rolls,” he said. “What’s costing America is not that there’s too many people on insurance, that’s not the reason. The reason is the cost of insurance and cost of health care is too expensive. This impacts nothing on that end.”

He said, while everyone should get behind finding a solution to reduce the costs of health care, this bill is not the answer, and whatever policy choice is made, it should be done thinking about patients first, in a careful, deliberate manner.

Likewise, Toni DiChiacchio, president of the West Virginia Nurses Association and a former nurse practitioner, said expanding Medicaid to cover people making up to 138 percent of the federal poverty level was paramount to the health of West Virginians, and rolling it back could be devastating.

“As West Virginians, the expansion has been incredible,” she said. “We are the most successful in the nation with getting people covered, and we fear what will happen with those people, should these [bills] pass. We’re not really hearing about options for this group of people other than high-risk pools, which traditionally have not worked well. We also have, as was mentioned here, this significant opiate problem, and that is not just a singular, as Dr. Gupta says, issue. There are physical and mental issues that go along with that. Without insurance to help pay for those services that those folks need, we’ll never have a healthy West Virginia.”

Along with the medical professionals, Lora Wilkerson spoke at the conference about her granddaughter, Elinor. The child was diagnosed with Rhabdomyosarcoma, a form of cancer, when she was 18 months old.

Elinor is 3 years old now and cancer-free, after 43 rounds of chemotherapy and six rounds of radiation. However, Wilkerson said she still has a long road ahead of her in physical, occupational and speech therapy, given the damage the cancer did to her.

Wilkerson said she’s worried what would happen to her granddaughter if insurance providers can up-charge people with pre-existing conditions or impose lifetime caps on coverage, practices that were outlawed under the ACA.

She said she just hopes Capito and other senators are thinking about who will feel the effects of the bill.

“Please stop and think about our West Virginians, children, the elderly, your family members, neighbors and co-workers. Stop and think about them, and do what’s right for them,” she said. “Let’s create something better, not throw everyone off. Work on something. Let’s fix it — don’t get rid of it.”

Reach Jake Zuckerman at, 304-348-4814 or follow @jake_zuckerman on Twitter.

Show All Comments Hide All Comments

User Comments

More News