Nationally-Recognized, Quality Local Journalism..

Click here to stay informed and subscribe to the Mountain State’s Trusted News Source.

Click #isupportlocal for more information on supporting our local journalists.

Learn more about HD Media

It’s the Sunday after Thanksgiving and, if you’re anything like me, you’re done with baking for a while.

At Thanksgiving I bake turkey, side dishes, rolls and pies. After it’s over, I just want something quick and easy that can feed our family and provide enough in case neighbors or friends drop in. Soup fits that bill.

I think of soup as the ultimate comfort food that is great when chilly weather hits.

My favorite soup recipe — of course — has a story behind it. My very good friend, Lisa, and her family, moved to the Hilton Head area from West Virginia a few years ago. We vacation at Kiawah, which is not too far of a drive from there, so we are able to see each other a couple of times each year.

Last year, we met Lisa, her husband and daughter at one of our favorite Kiawah restaurants. All of us ordered salad before dinner, except Lisa — who ordered the soup of the day. When it arrived, she tasted it and immediately insisted we all do so as well. It was an unusual combination of potato soup with fresh parmesan and the result was definitely spectacular.

After we returned home from our trip, Lisa and I continued to talk about how good the soup was. We hatched a plan to scour the internet in search of the recipe (or one that came close).

Each of us chose a different parmesan potato soup from two different websites and promised to share results. We both reported back that neither recipe came close to the one we had tasted at the restaurant.

Disheartened, I decided I was going to call and ask the chef if he would give me the recipe or at least share the ingredient list. I called on a weekday afternoon hoping the chef might be available.

Stories you might like

The hostess said he was busy preparing dinner but if I sent an email to the restaurant, she would see that it got to him. I composed a quick message telling him how much we had enjoyed the soup and asked if he might share his recipe. I figured that would be the end of it and he would not respond.

I was shocked to open my email the next morning to find he had indeed responded with the full recipe, although he apologized that the ingredients were proportioned to the massive quantities he prepared in the restaurant. I mathematically adjusted the recipe for a much smaller batch and made the soup.

The ingredient quantity adjustments weren’t correct once reduced (super salty and garlicy) and it took me several tries (actually, days) of adjusting them to arrive at the recipe I’m sharing here. Lisa and I agree this one tastes just like the soup she was served that night. I hope you love it as much as my family does.

Interestingly enough, another one of the recipes I’m sharing comes from the same soup-loving friend, Lisa, who had a crockpot full of her Beef Barley Vegetable Soup waiting when we met her in Hilton Head for a girl’s weekend last year.

We had left after work one day and arrived around midnight without dinner, so this soup really hit the spot for all of us. That particular night, Lisa forgot to put the vegetables in the recipe but it was still amazing.

The tortellini soup recipe I’m sharing is a concoction I’ve been serving my family for years. I started the base from a copycat recipe of Olive Garden’s Zuppa Toscana Soup. I’ve tweaked it to my family’s tastes and added ingredients like tortellini and tomato paste. This is the meal that my son asks for when he comes home for college.

I hope you find a recipe here that you can easily make and serve your family as December arrives and the busy holidays are upon us. Serve it with your favorite crusty bread and a glass of wine to savor this ultimate comfort food.

Sarah Long is the author of the cookbook “College Cooking 101: Fast Food Without a Kitchen.” You can contact her at and follow her on social media on facebook @SarahHLongAuthor, Instagram @CollegeCooking101, and Twitter @SarahHLong1.

Recommended for you