Steven Paine: Test scores not only measure of success

Essential reporting in volatile times.

Not a Subscriber yet? Click here to take advantage of All access digital limited time offer $5.99 per month EZ Pay.

Interested in Donating? Click #ISupportLocal for more information on supporting local journalism.

steven paine

steven paine

Steven L. Paine

There are many measures of student achievement. We are all familiar with the multitude of standardized tests that measure student achievement each year. But these are not the only — and perhaps not even the best — way to measure the success of our students.

What about the impact students have on their community? What about a student’s ability to communicate and work in a team? What about students who earn high-level industry recognized credentials? What impact do they have on providing West Virginia with a highly skilled workforce?

When considering education’s impact on the state’s economy and the ability of students to find high-wage employment, the other measures of student achievement are extremely important. If you ask business leaders, they will tell you that soft skills are even more important than standardized test scores when considering a potential hire.

According to a 2017 survey by the National Association of Colleges and Employers, the “ability to work in a team” was the most desired attribute of a potential employee. Teamwork was followed closely by written and verbal communication skills and was listed ahead of analytical/quantitative skills and other attributes that are emphasized in formal educational settings. The skill sets revered by businesses are often found in our successful career technical education students. These students perform at a high level in their classroom because they have real buy-in to their learning.

According to the 2018-19 National Occupational Competency Testing Institute assessment, a series of tests to determine CTE students’ level of workforce readiness, West Virginia students performed 21 percent above the workplace entry-level and 6 percent above the national average on workforce readiness standards in 10 key industry CTE programs as identified by the West Virginia Department of Commerce.

So, why do our students perform so well on these tests? The answer is simple: it means something to them, and students see value in the test.

In order to provide students with demand-driven skills that will set them up for career success, the West Virginia Department of Education and state businesses collaborated to create the Simulated Workplace — powerful learning environments that transform the traditional classroom into student-led companies that replicate real-world work experiences. West Virginia’s Simulated Workplace companies prepare our students not only to participate in the future workplace, but to lead it.

A foundational pillar of Simulated Workplace is entrepreneurship. Students are exposed to mathematics and English language arts concepts through mastery of accounting, marketing, branding and bookkeeping for their student-led companies. Administrators and educators tell us that students are excited to come to school and learn because of the Simulated Workplace model.

Although entrepreneurship has always been a defining pillar of the Simulated Workplace, the West Virginia Department of Education is taking entrepreneurship to a higher level by intentionally carving out a dedicated Entrepreneurship Pathway in 11 CTE centers throughout the state. The West Virginia Department of Education partnered with Marshall University’s iCenter, former Intuit Chairman and CEO Brad Smith and Intuit Education to develop this pathway model that will be used throughout the state and nationally.

There has been much talk of the state’s need to push the economy in new areas, and it will be today’s students who do just that. According to WVU’s Bureau of Business and Economic Research Director John Deskins’ annual report delivered during the recent West Virginia Economic Outlook Conference, “Given the complexity that we see in the real world, nobody really, really knows how to diversify our economy or where to diversify our economy until somebody tries it. That’s why it all boils down to entrepreneurship.”

Within the Entrepreneurship Pathway, we are already seeing creative ideas that could impact West Virginia. Students are putting their ideas into action, and their work is being noticed.

Recently, students at Lincoln County High School received a grant from MIT to help with the design and implementation of a wind tunnel project that could have a major impact on the agricultural community. Students at Calhoun-Gilmer Career Center received a grant from Sony to develop smart-home technology that could keep an aging population safe in their own homes for longer.

When Smith met with Simulated Workplace students last month, his excitement about the new program was palpable as he expressed the importance of entrepreneurship skills in development of the 21st century workforce. Smith sees West Virginia’s potential to be the next Silicon Valley, and the creativity and excitement for learning experienced in Simulated Workplace companies gives me hope that this could be a real possibility for the Mountain State.

In spring 2020, students participating in the pilot of the Entrepreneurship Pathway will present their ideas in a showcase at Marshall University.

Test scores are important, but they are just a snapshot of a small sample of students in a single moment in time. The true test of West Virginia’s education system is determined by the quality of the emerging workforce. The real future of West Virginia is fueled by students. They are bright. They are technically skilled. They are innovative, and I am confident in the future they are building in the Mountain State.

Steven L. Paine is superintendent of schools in West Virginia.

Funerals for Monday, July 13, 2020

Alford, Virginia - 11 a.m., Apple Grove Memorial Gardens.

Gibson, Harold - 1 p.m., Fidler & Frame Funeral Home, Belle.

Humphreys Sr., Randall - 2:30 p.m., Ward Road Cemetery, Nettie.

Jackson, Shirley - 1 p.m., Bollinger Funeral Home, Charleston.

Laudermilt, Darlene - 7 p.m., Foglesong - Casto Funeral Home, Mason.

Nichols, Sharon - 1 p.m., Keller Funeral Home, Dunbar.

Sammons, Anthony - 2 p.m., Handley Funeral Home, Danville.

Tucker, Denver - 3 p.m., Rayne Funeral Home, Eleanor Chapel.